Save Jennie Stuart, a group advocating for the preservation of Jennie Stuart Medical Center in Hopkinsville, Kentucky, has taken legal action to halt Deaconess Health’s proposed acquisition of the hospital. The lawsuit, filed against the hospital’s board of directors, alleges that the board has breached its fiduciary duties by agreeing to transfer the hospital and its assets to Deaconess without adequate consideration for the community.
The plaintiffs conducted an investigation into the value of Jennie Stuart Medical Center, consulting with financial experts who estimated the hospital’s book value to be over $157 million. They criticized the four-person committee responsible for the transaction, accusing them of undervaluing the hospital and lacking the expertise to handle such a significant merger.
Save Jennie Stuart also raised concerns about the transaction process, citing nondisclosure of material information to the governing board, lack of valuation, and conflicts of interest among board members. They are seeking a restraining order, preliminary injunction, and permanent injunction to prevent the transaction from proceeding.
In response to the lawsuit, the Jennie Stuart Health Board of Trustees defended the proposed acquisition, stating that it would enhance local healthcare quality and strengthen the hospital’s ability to serve the community long-term. The board emphasized that they conducted a thorough evaluation process, considering multiple options with the guidance of financial and legal advisors.
The legal dispute reflects a larger trend in the healthcare industry, where hospitals and health systems are moving towards strategic partnerships rather than pursuing scale through mergers and acquisitions. This shift allows organizations to access new technologies, tools, and investments to support their goals of system reconfiguration.
As the legal battle unfolds, the future of Jennie Stuart Medical Center hangs in the balance, with both sides committed to their respective visions for the hospital’s role in the Hopkinsville community. The outcome of the lawsuit will ultimately shape the trajectory of healthcare delivery in the region, highlighting the complexities of balancing financial considerations with community needs.
For more healthcare news and updates, visit Healthcare Finance News, a HIMSS Media publication.
