After the federal government shutdown, Julio Fuentes stood near the Capitol building in Washington D.C., delivering a crucial message about the Hispanic voters who played a significant role in helping the Republican Party come to power last year.
Fuentes, the president of the Hispanic Chamber of Commerce of Florida, warned that these votes are at risk if Congress does not pass a law to keep monthly costs low for the marketplace plans established by the Affordable Care Act (ACA) for around 4.7 million people in his home state of Florida who rely on this coverage.
“Hispanic voters helped Donald Trump return to the White House,” Fuentes emphasized. “Republican leaders would do well to keep healthcare coverage accessible, as their voters will remember this as the legislative elections approach.”
As the deadline for many individuals to choose their health plans for the upcoming year approaches, Democrats in Congress have blocked the approval of government funds to pressure Republicans. The aim is to extend billions of dollars in federal subsidies that have significantly lowered monthly costs in recent years, leading to a record number of people having health insurance.
This political moment is seen by Democrats as an opportunity to address the importance of accessible healthcare, especially as millions of people, including those with coverage through work or Medicare, are facing higher costs next year.
In an effort to regain the support of some working-class voters who have drifted away, party leaders have highlighted the recent healthcare cuts approved by Republicans.
On the other hand, Republicans publicly express confidence that this strategy will not have an impact, reminding people that it was the Democrats who caused the government shutdown. However, a new analysis by KFF reveals that 80% of all premium subsidies benefited individuals enrolled in states won by Trump.
The shutdown coincides with the start of the open enrollment season, with insurers preparing to send notices with next year’s rates to approximately 24 million people enrolled in ACA plans.
If the subsidies expire, the average monthly cost for beneficiaries is expected to double. Insurers have also warned that they may have to significantly increase premium prices, as many healthy individuals may opt out of coverage if it becomes too expensive, leaving a pool of insured individuals who are sicker and with fewer resources to cover them.
“In the coming days, over 20 million Americans will see drastic increases in their premiums, copays, and deductibles because Republicans refuse to extend the subsidies of the Affordable Care Act,” stated Hakeem Jeffries, the minority leader in the House of Representatives, on October 2nd at the Capitol steps.
In most states, open enrollment begins on November 1st. Some insurers and state marketplaces have delayed sending out rate notices for next year as they await developments in Washington. For example, Covered California, the state’s insurance marketplace, plans to send notices to over a million enrolled individuals later than usual this year, by October 15th.
Natalie Tyer, 31, from Richmond, Virginia, anxiously awaits her notice from the state marketplace, checking the website daily for updates on her plan’s new rates. Tyer has relied on marketplace coverage for over a year while working part-time at a local video production company and pursuing a master’s degree to become a school counselor. The subsidies cover $255 of her monthly premium, reducing her payment to $53. As she is generally healthy, a significant increase in premiums due to the expiration of credits may force her to forgo coverage.
“I might have to go without health insurance and rely on hope,” Tyer expressed.
While Democrats seek to center the government shutdown debate on healthcare costs, the reality of the shutdown includes millions of unpaid federal employees, disrupted public health agency functions, and the risk of halting food assistance payments for low-income mothers, among other consequences.
ACA has been a political flashpoint since its establishment in 2010, with Republicans opposing the landmark health law. Subsequent Republican electoral victories led to another government shutdown in 2013 when attempts were made to dismantle the program. In 2017, Republican leaders once again sought to repeal the law as part of Trump’s campaign promise.
The current conflict surrounding the billions of dollars in subsidies championed by Democrats during the COVID-19 pandemic to boost ACA enrollment has been simmering for months.
The same Democrats who crafted the legislation introducing and later expanding these benefits set the enhanced subsidies to expire by the end of this year. Even some Republicans warned this summer that allowing them to lapse could be detrimental. Republican pollsters Tony Fabrizio and Bob Ward released a memo cautioning that extending the credits could make a difference in next year’s legislative elections.
Extending ACA subsidies, which have reduced monthly premiums to as low as $0 or $10 for low-income individuals and capped spending for middle-income earners at just 8.5% of their salaries, is also a popular measure among many Americans.
Over three-quarters of Americans want these subsidies to continue, according to a recent KFF survey conducted before the shutdown. Approximately three out of four individuals stated they would blame Trump or the Republican Party if the subsidies were canceled.
While Republicans have declined to address the issue so far this year, party leaders have indicated a willingness to extend them with new eligibility restrictions. They have also expressed a desire to discuss policy details over several weeks, rather than under the pressure of a shutdown.
On October 6th, House Speaker Mike Johnson accused Democrats of manufacturing a political problem to shut down the government and urged them to pass the continuing resolution solely to “keep healthcare.”
“They decided they would pick a fight over healthcare,” Johnson stated, suggesting that he believes the subsidies are a “December 31st issue,” referring to the anticipated expiration date.
With open enrollment commencing next month, insurers must start publishing premium prices for customers to compare in the coming days. Democrats argue that waiting months to reach an agreement, which could alter these prices, may lead to widespread confusion.
While more Americans appear to blame Trump and the Republicans for the government shutdown, only a quarter of the population is convinced that the Democratic proposal to extend ACA subsidies justifies the shutdown, according to a CBS News poll conducted over the October 4th weekend.
Healthcare is often a winning message for Democrats, who have struggled to unify around issues appealing to the working class in recent years, noted William Pierce, a healthcare policy consultant who worked during the George W. Bush presidency.
“It all revolves around healthcare. They need this to revolve around healthcare. They need to keep talking about it constantly,” Pierce remarked.
Republicans in the White House and Congress have countered with claims, based on dubious facts, that Democrats seek to expand free healthcare for undocumented immigrants.
In reality, these immigrants cannot enroll in the health insurance marketplace, and Democrats have not proposed extending ACA coverage to them in their plan.
Back in Richmond, as Tyer worries about her coverage for the upcoming year, she is also concerned about the focus on immigrants in the debate. Some of her classmates and colleagues share the same apprehensions.
“The reality is that what is happening with these subsidies is that ordinary people – those who want to work in the public sector, those who want to educate their children – we are also going to lose healthcare,” Tyer emphasized.
Senior correspondent of KFF Health News, Bernard J. Wolfson, contributed to this report.
For more information or to submit a story tip, you can contact us.
