Sam’s Club is known for its wide selection of party-friendly treats, and one of its most popular bakery items is making a triumphant return. The beloved cookie cake is back just in time for Valentine’s Day, much to the delight of fans who have been eagerly awaiting its comeback.
In a recent Instagram post, Sam’s Club announced the return of the extra-large cookie cake with a simple caption that read, “Cookie cake is back. That’s it. That’s the post.” The post featured a video showcasing the decadent dessert, which consists of two giant chocolate chip cookie slabs with a layer of fluffy frosting in between.
While the premade cookie cakes will be available in stores, customers also have the option to customize their cake to suit their event. Many shoppers have expressed their excitement over the return of the cookie cake, with some reminiscing about how the treat was a staple for special occasions. One Instagram user commented, “My kids will be so happy!! Birthdays haven’t been the same without your cookie cakes,” while another wrote, “Best news of 2025! How soon @samsclub? We have birthdays coming up!”
Despite the initial announcement stating that the cookie cakes would hit store shelves on Feb. 1, some members have reported difficulty finding the treat in stock at their local clubs. This is not uncommon with new releases, as the rollout can sometimes be slow. If your store doesn’t have the cookie cake yet, it’s recommended to call or check back in next week.
For those who can’t wait to get their hands on a cookie cake, there’s always the option to bake one at home. By using a favorite cookie recipe and transforming it into cake form, or by trying out a homemade cookie cake recipe with personalized mix-ins, you can still enjoy this delicious dessert for your upcoming special occasion. Just don’t forget the frosting!
